Friday, February 27, 2015

Changes (a book review post)

For those of you unfamiliar with The Dresden Files, you do not want to start with this book, book 12 in the series. While each book has an intact story that doesn't exactly require the previous books to understand, there is so much back story built up that, even though Butcher does a fairly decent job of quickly filling in details about past events/people, a lot of the context will be lost. Besides, it's a good series and, if you want to read them, you should just start at book one, Storm Front.

If you've been around for a while, you'll know that book 11, Turn Coat, was the first of the Dresden books that I haven't been in love with (or extreme like). And, wow, it was enough to allow me to go a whole year before picking up Changes. I thought about it several times over the past year but, every time I did, I decided to go with some other book. I suppose a streak of reading books I didn't enjoy much prompted me to go ahead with book 12.

The first thing I will note is that the editing is much better in this one. Although there are more commas than are strictly needed, there are none just stuck into the middles of clauses. At least not so many that I noticed them like in the last book.

The idea behind this book is right in the title. Butcher has decided to change Dresden's life, really shake it up. The one thing I have really liked about the Dresden books is that Dresden is not a static character. This is not one of those series where everything goes back to the status quo at the end of each book, which is why you can't pick the books up at random and read them. If you don't read them in order, you can't follow the overall story arc and the growth of the character. The truth is that change is a normal thing for Harry Dresden. Well, except for the fact that he can't ever seem to get ahead. But there are far-reaching consequences in these books that you don't always see in series fiction like this where each book has a happy ending and everything is fine again. Dresden may get the technical happy ending, but nothing is ever fine.

In this one, though, Butcher goes after Dresden hard.

In fact, it's so hard that it's like someone walking up to you on the street and just punching you in the face. Which is kind of the problem, because Butcher picks one of the most cliche ways of doing that: "They've taken our daughter." That's sentence one, and, of course, Dresden didn't know anything about having a kid. Nor should he have because it was from a singular sexual encounter. I'm just going to say, really, only teenagers expect people to believe that you can have sex once and get pregnant.

Sure, I know that it's technically possible, and teenagers, which I know from years of working with them, want adults to believe that, really, they only slipped up the one time and, oops!, pregnant. The reality, though, is that that pregnancy is the result of two humping like bunnies for months. So it's really kind of insulting for Butcher to throw the unknown kid at us from the one sexual encounter Dresden had with the mother years before.

But that's (almost) the only complaint I have about the book. Once you get past the whole "I have to go rescue my daughter" thing, it's a well constructed story. Butcher systematically goes through and dismantles Dresden's life and even managed to throw in a couple of things I didn't see coming. That doesn't happen for me very often. [In fact, the big problem I had with book 11 is that I knew who the bad guy was and what was going on by about 1/4 of the way through the book. The rest of it was just going through the motions.] I don't mind Dresden having a daughter. I don't even mind that he didn't know he had a daughter. I mind that it's the result of this one time thing that happened. Beyond that, this book is a great ride.

Oh, I did say "almost" the only complaint. The other thing is the cliffhanger that Butcher threw in on, literally, the last page. I won't say what happened, but I find just tossing that in at the end to be about as cliche as the beginning. So, yeah, take out the first page and the last page and this is an awesome book. Unfortunately, the reliance on those two gimmicks takes the book down a peg for me. It's still a great series, though, and I would highly recommend it to any fan of fantasy, especially modern fantasy.

22 comments:

  1. Thanks for the review! I have Storm Front, and I started it, but I didn't like the book as much as I liked the TV series. I imagine the same thing would happen if someone wrote a series about Sam & Dean of "Supernatural" or Buffy of her series. I love comedy in horror TV, but for some reason it doesn't translate as well for me on the printed page. I hope you enjoy #13 as much as you enjoyed this one!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Lexa: I didn't like the TV series at all. Compared to the books, it was completely flat and gimmicky. And the difference in your TV comparisons is that Dresden started as a book, not the other way around.

      Delete
  2. I read Storm Front and I loved the show when it was (all too briefly) on. I should probably get the next book in the series...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. mshatch: Like I said to Lexa, the TV show doesn't even come close to the books.

      Delete
  3. I have heard about this series from friends, but it's not my genre, at all, so I likely won't be picking it up. I do appreciate how gimmicks can wreck an otherwise good story, however.

    Your comment about pregnancy made me laugh. In my life I've had 3 of 5 conceptions from a single, unplanned, unprotected encounter with the hubs. (One was an immediate post-partum conception that was ectopic!) The only "planned" child we ever conceived took three months of "work". Go figure.
    V:)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Veronica: The problem with your statement is that you haven't had "single" encounters with your husband. Unless you're saying that you only have unprotected sex like once a year, and, even then, there is a huge difference in physical reaction even if the you are only having unprotected sex once a year. At any rate, it's nothing like having sex for the first time in years and getting pregnant from it.

      Delete
  4. I'm lost as to which books I have read and not. I am sure I have read another beyond Changes, oh, I just read there is a #13. I too am familiar with single experiences leading to conception.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Jo: Sure, they happen, but they are still extremely rare. It's like amnesia. Amnesia is a real thing but, if we were basing its occurrence by how often it happens in stories, everyone you know would have had some sort of amnesia experience at some point in their lives.

      Delete
  5. I'm totally unfamiliar with this series, but it sounds really interesting. Thanks for sharing!

    ReplyDelete
  6. I read the first book which was ok.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Pat: A lot of people say that whole thing "they get better," and, while that is true (which they should, because he's been writing these books for more than a decade and there would be something wrong if they didn't get better), I like the first one more than enough to go on to the next.

      Delete
  7. I heard some people grumbling about series decay for the Dresden Files, but for the most part it seems to be holding up.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Jeanne: I didn't like Turn Coat as much, but, at this point, I'd call that an aberration, not decay.

      Delete
  8. Sounds like the series has, at least, hooked you back in.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I don't know what modern fantasy is but interesting review.
    Don't your dislike when you get to an end of a book and the author who has been writing for 18 days straight to finish, throws in the worst ending ever.
    I just read some of your older post, what a hoot the birthday one was.
    Naughty family eating your leftovers.

    cheers, parsnip


    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. parsnip: Modern fantasy is just taking the classical fantasy elements and setting them now. What would it be like to have wizards (and all that goes with them) in today?

      They were naughty!

      Delete
  10. Whoa? Book TWELVE? I'm tired just thinking of that many books in the same series!

    ReplyDelete
  11. Stephanie: I can understand that, but, at least, it's serial and not just one, long unending story.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Yesterday I was looking at my copy of "The Golden Compass" and wishing for a series of books that would equal that, or Lord of the Rings, or another epic fantasy that has a beginning and middle and end. This came up on a lot of lists, but it doesn't sound like it quite meets my goal, if it's 12 books that just keep telling new stories.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Briane: The only thing I've read that I would suggest is The Belgariad, but I would highly recommend that.

      Delete